Don’t get me wrong, I love young adult literature. I go through these books as if I was still a teenager and they are, in my opinion, very entertaining. I read the Twillight saga in less than two weeks and was almost screaming like a little girl every time a new Harry Potter came out, to mention only a few. I cannot wait to read The Wolves of Mercy Falls Trilogy written by Maggie Stiefvater and many mores.
The only problem I have is that, even if they feel comfortable as a cafe latte on a Sunday morning, the use of cliches is getting a bit frustrating, in my opinion. I’ve come up with a list of the ones that we need to let go once and for all.
- An immortal a couple of centuries old falls in love with a bright and independent teenager: Let’s get back in real life for a moment. An adult man falling in love with a teenage girl is purely creepy, not to mention illegal. An immortal has to be how old so that those rules do not apply to him? Is 100 years old enough?
- An immortal a couple of centuries old falls in love with a bright and independent teenager: Yeah, Yeah, Yeah. I know. It’s identical to number one, but I believe this one is twofold. How come a more mature man who has lived through different eras and who has seen and lived some many things can fall in love with a teenage girl? Have you ever seen a teenage girl? The drama, the makeup, the cell phones, the gossip. OMG, how can someone over 20 years old deal with that or even fall in love with that? I have to admit that I’ve added this one out of jealousy. Damn you Edward! How come you did not choose me?
- The almost inevitable prophecy: Too many have fallen for this one. It is easier to write about an old prophecy to give your main character an edge than to develop your story. I get it. I’ve done it. However, it brings nothing new to the table. It’s been done a million times already, and if you are not able to do it as good as J.R.R. Tolkien in Lord of the Rings than don’t do it.
- The chosen one: She/he lives a normal life until things start falling apart and he/she learns that she/he is the ”chosen one” that will save them all. Sounds familiar? This one often goes hand in hand with number 3 (The Prophecy). The character then goes on finding a force that she/he did not knew that she/he had before all of this began and usually triumphs in the end fulfilling the prophecy of being the chosen one. Which makes me wonder, have you ever read a story implying number 3 and 4 were the character did not fulfill his destiny ultimately? (feel free to discuss this in the comment section)
- The young brilliant, mature and witty teenager that seems like an old soul: We sometime feel as a writer that we need to emphasis on the maturity and the ”out of the ordinary” aspect of our main teen character. However, I read a book recently that made me think otherwise. The book is called Alyss and is written by a French writer from Quebec, Patrick Senécal, that I love. I would describe this book as a strange version of Alice in Wonderland. His main character, Alice is an eighteen years old girl that just left her parent’s house. She talks like a teenager, and she acts like one. She has the revolutionary ideas that a normal teenager would have but that will not stand the test of time. She is what she is, and she is interesting that way. My point is, teenagers are great creatures whom we need to depict as they are, and not as we would like them to be from our adult point of view. Sure I would like to be the mother of a mature, intelligent and witty 16 years old that loves to read classic literature. That might be the case, but in real life, teenagers are conflicted, they feel misunderstood, and they sometime act without thinking. And that is what makes them great! They should not be depicted as thirthysomethings who are attending high school.
That being said, I am not here to judge. Many writers will use these cliches and transform them into something wonderful. We just have to think of so many characters that have won our hearts even though they fell under one or many of these (Harry Potter, Bella/Edward, Frodo, etc.).
Heck, the first novel I wanted to write was based on a sixteen year old girl, a.k.a. the chosen one, that needed to fulfill a prophecy to save the world but could rely on her matureness and intelligence to seduce the immortal who was sent to kill her (not to mention that this guy was almost 500 years old!). This novel was never finished. I decided that at one point it felt too familiar, and that I did not bring anything new to the table.
It would not be fair to say that cliches should not be used at all. Use them if you strongly believe that they are absolutely necessary to your story line. Try to turn them around and see if you can make them truly unique in your own way. Maybe the prophecy will not be fulfilled, or the chosen one might not be the only solution to the whole situation. In short, be creative!
